Over the last two posts I've interviewed Matthew Federman and the writing team of Gregg Rossen and Brian Sawyer on writing partnerships. Today, I'm continuing that topic with an email interview with Paul Guay (Liar Liar, Heartbreakers, The Little Rascals).
Before I get to Paul, I noticed doing these interviews that the writers often brought up working with partners on pitches and in meetings. This points to one of the truths of being a professional screenwriter - it's about more than just writing screenplays. Something to think about if you're considering a partnership. And now with a few more things to think about, here's my interview with Paul Guay:
Q. You’ve worked with different writing partners...
Q. ...and also done some writing on your own. How did you find your writing partners, and how do you decide who you want to work with?
A. I’ve had about four and a half writing partners.
One and a half were friends from high school, one was an upperclassman whom I probably didn’t meet in high school but whose name I knew, one was a friend of two of my college friends, and one I met on the WGA picket line.
I knew all of them socially before we began writing together, except my fellow picketer.
The high-school friends were improvising comedy sketches into a tape recorder and had written a couple of comedy sketches when I joined them. I loved their writing, loved their performing, and joined because I wanted to write and perform with them. Later the three of us wrote a comedy-sketch screenplay together, and I partnered with one of them on three non-sketch screenplays and a teleplay.
The friend of two college friends approached me with the idea for a screenplay and suggested we write it together. I liked the idea and was interested in getting serious about screenwriting, so I agreed. The partnership eventually led to The Little Rascals, Liar, Liar and Heartbreakers.
The upperclassman mentioned an idea for a screenplay. I loved the idea, and one of us (I forget which) suggested we write the screenplay together.
While we were picketing, my fellow picketer mentioned a movie idea he had. I was so drawn to the idea that I began pitching bits and characters and scenes to him. I eventually proposed that we write the story together and, if that went well, the screenplay. He agreed.
Q. What process do you prefer? Do you sit in the same room or do you send material back and forth?
A. Most of the collaborative work has been done in the same room, which has its costs and benefits.
Q. What happens when you disagree with your writing partner? How do you make decisions?
A. I learned through experience that the answer(s) to this question, and to all other questions regarding a writing partnership, should be spelled out in advance in a written contract.
Subsequently, I have collaborated only when there is a contract in place.
Here’s a pertinent clause from a recent collaboration agreement:
“During the writing and any rewriting thereof, whether on spec or under contract, when there is a creative disagreement between Writer A and Writer B, they will explore good-faith ways of resolving the disagreement. Such methods may include:
(i) Reasoned argument;
(ii) Each party’s making a good-faith estimate of the importance he places on the issue, with the party giving the issue less weight conceding to the other;
(iii) Alternating concessions; and
(iv) Flipping a coin.
If these methods, or any others the parties attempt, do not satisfactorily resolve the issue, or if in Writer A’s opinion the issue is too important to subject to one of these methods, then Writer A’s decision will control, but only after giving due consideration to Writer B’s position.”
Q. What are the advantages of working with a partner?
A. You cut your taxes in half.
If you have the right working arrangement with the right partner (and keep in mind, that’s two big ifs):
Having a partner provides discipline; you will show up and put in the hours.
Having a partner makes brainstorming easier; two minds can spark each other better than one mind can spark itself.
Having a partner provides a sounding board to choose between and organize various ideas.
Having a partner with complementary strengths can make the screenplay better.
Having a partner puts someone in your corner, which can be helpful in meetings.
And having a partner means someone is sharing the responsibility, which can be helpful during moments of self-doubt and the dark night of the soul.
Q. What are the disadvantages?
A. You cut your taxes in half.
If you want to protect your solo voice (at least in the spec or first-draft phase), writing with a partner is probably not the best choice.
If you find you and your partner are not compatible, because of personality (you’re too different, or too similar) or any other reason, things can go south in spectacular ways.
Q. Any advice for a writer contemplating entering into a writing partnership?
A. Don’t... unless the benefits outweigh the costs.
In that case, do.
Discuss the nature and conditions of the partnership in advance, and put the conclusions of those discussions in a contract written or vetted by an attorney or two.
Answers (c) 2015 Paul Guay. All rights reserved.
* * *
Paul Guay’s movies have grossed over half a billion dollars. He conceived and co-wrote Liar, Liar, at the time of its release the sixth-highest-grossing comedy in history. The screenplay received an Honorable Mention (along with Fargo, Million Dollar Baby, The Full Monty and Catch Me If You Can) in Scr(i)pt magazine’s list of the Best Scripts of the Past 10 Years.
Paul co-wrote The Little Rascals, Universal's second-highest-grossing film of its year, and co-wrote Heartbreakers, starring Sigourney Weaver, Jennifer Love Hewitt, Gene Hackman and Jason Lee, which opened #1 at the box office, and the rights to which he co-licensed to MGM for production as a stage musical.
Paul teaches screenwriting at Art Center College of Design and through The Film Connection and is a sought-after Script Consultant.